论文

CaRT+水文模型以35个参数逼近LSTM精度,覆盖三大洲1195个流域

From hydrological laws to catchment models: A process-based model matches deep-learning accuracy on three continents

精选理由

物理模型真的能打过LSTM了:CaRT+每流域才35个参数,在澳大利亚505个流域上反超两个LSTM,做水文的同学可以看看.

论文提出仅含35个参数每流域的物理过程模型CaRT+,用于流域径流模拟。在英国602个和 美国593个流域的留出年份上,CaRT+的中位Nash-Sutcliffe效率达到0.863和0.765,与单模型LSTM(0.869/0.751)相当。在未参与开发的505个澳大利亚流域上,CaRT+达到0.778,超过两个LSTM的0.762和0.753。模型的改进通过AI智能体辅助的循环完成,每一步都基于文献假设解决观测到的模拟偏差。

原文 · arXiv cs.LG

From hydrological laws to catchment models: A process-based model matches deep-learning accuracy on three continents

Dooge asked whether hydrology has laws at the catchment scale. We ask whether a low-dimensional system built under physical laws can match the accuracy of neural networks that outperform process-based models on the same inputs. Three laws constrain a lumped catchment model. Conservation makes it a flux-connected storage network, dissipation fixes the sign of every flux and aggregation determines how the unresolved composition enters the fluxes, through effective laws over threshold distributions and a memory of the forcing. These laws admit four kinds of refinement. A parsimonious model under them, CaRT (11 parameters per catchment), is refined in a loop assisted by AI agents. Each refinement addresses an observed deficit through a hypothesis from the literature. The result, CaRT+, has fourteen states, 35 parameters per catchment and no daily neural network. Most refinements follow from aggregation over thresholds or from variables that carry no water but modulate fluxes. On 602 British and 593 US gauged catchments, single CaRT+ models reach median Nash-Sutcliffe efficiencies of 0.863 and 0.765 in held-out years. A stateful LSTM reaches 0.869 and 0.751 and an entity-aware LSTM 0.862 and 0.754, while three-seed LSTM ensembles remain ahead of the CaRT+ ensemble by 0.003-0.012 in median paired NSE. On 505 drier Australian gauged catchments unused in development, single CaRT+ models reach 0.778 against 0.762 and 0.753 for the two LSTMs. The results suggest that catchment-scale laws exist as laws of form, with the constitutive families shared and only their parameters learned.