Gary Marcus 调侃 Elon Musk 提出"SI"取代"AI"的提法
Musk 想把 AI 改叫 SI(超级智能),Marcus 直接列了一堆例子吐槽:按这标准 ELIZA 和 Deep Blue 也算?定义之争挺有意思。
Elon Musk 在 X 上提议用 SI(Superintelligence)取代 AI 这一叫法。Gary Marcus 对此发帖反驳,列举了 ELIZA(1965)、Deep Blue、谷歌早期搜索算法和初版 ChatGPT 等例子,指出如果按此逻辑这些系统都该算"超级智能"。Marcus 还调侃按该标准自己的 Apple Watch 也算超级智能。该争议核心在于 SI 概念的界定模糊。
So let me get this straight, now we have to call every piece of AI SI, even • ELIZA, 1965 which was just keyword matching and certainly not super or intelligent • Deep Blue, which could play chess but nothing else. • The original Google search algorithm (which could only do search and nothing else). • The original ChatGPT (which was so unreliable and hallucinatory that it more of a demo than a product) etc RIght? Guess that makes my Apple Watch Super Intelligent, too! Elon Musk @elonmusk No more AI SI It’s better 🔗 View Quoted Tweet 💬 6 🔄 1 ❤️ 11 👀 1420 📊 5 ⚡