行业

Gary Marcus 调侃 Elon Musk 提出"SI"取代"AI"的提法

精选理由

Musk 想把 AI 改叫 SI(超级智能),Marcus 直接列了一堆例子吐槽:按这标准 ELIZA 和 Deep Blue 也算?定义之争挺有意思。

Elon Musk 在 X 上提议用 SI(Superintelligence)取代 AI 这一叫法。Gary Marcus 对此发帖反驳,列举了 ELIZA(1965)、Deep Blue、谷歌早期搜索算法和初版 ChatGPT 等例子,指出如果按此逻辑这些系统都该算"超级智能"。Marcus 还调侃按该标准自己的 Apple Watch 也算超级智能。该争议核心在于 SI 概念的界定模糊。

原文 · Gary Marcus

So let me get this straight, now we have to call every piece of AI SI, even • ELIZA, 1965 which was just keyword matching and certainly not super or intelligent • Deep Blue, which could play chess but nothing else. • The original Google search algorithm (which could only do search and nothing else). • The original ChatGPT (which was so unreliable and hallucinatory that it more of a demo than a product) etc RIght? Guess that makes my Apple Watch Super Intelligent, too! Elon Musk @elonmusk No more AI SI It’s better 🔗 View Quoted Tweet 💬 6 🔄 1 ❤️ 11 👀 1420 📊 5 ⚡