levelsio 评测 Matic 扫地机器人:摄像头视觉方案胜过 Roborock
levelsio 用了几个月 Matic 扫地机器人,说它靠摄像头认路、不卡电线,比 Roborock 好用太多,还查了它不上传家里数据。
开发者 levelsio(Pieter Levels)分享了对 Matic 扫地机器人几个月的使用体验。他此前的 Roborock 经常卡在电缆和厚地毯上,每次使用前都要先整理房间。Matic 采用摄像头环境理解方案,思路接近自动驾驶汽车,不会卡线缆和地毯,吸力和拖地能力均强于 Roborock,噪音也更低。他用 Claude 分析网络流量后确认 Matic 没有回传任何家庭数据。
It’s been a few months now testing the @maticrobots vacuum cleaner
Before we had a Roborock (essentially a Roomba knockoff)
But the Roborock became kinda useless, it'd always get stuck in any type of cable, it'd always get stuck not being able to get on to the thick rug, so you'd have to prep the room every single time just to use it
Too much work so we just stopped using it
The Matic is, well, completely different. It's not flat or low, it's a chunky tall kinda cute looking cube shaped thing with 2 big wheels
And it's a different philosophy, it has cameras and tries to understand its environment, more like a modern robot or a self driving Tesla than a classic Roomba-type vacuum
That makes it just way way better, it doesn't get stuck in cables, it doesn't get stuck in rugs, it drives and turns around the room almost like a mini car
It's also way more silent than Roborock or Roomba-type vacuums, and measurably way more powerful in both vacuuming and mopping
They also respond very fast to feedback and improve things fast, like companies should be these days (instead of getting stuck in some hellish corporate support flow)
Another thing, I don't trust consumer devices connected to the internet (and nor should you) so of course I asked to Claude to analyze if it was phoning home (remember the other vacuums who upload your house plan to China, that was true). Claude was conclusive, Matic never phoned home anything, excellent
Maybe the best part is, it just looks cute and you wanna anthropomorphize it, and they include 2 googly eye stickers so it becomes even more like a dog/cat/pet
@mehul made a great thing!