Gary Marcus 转发争议帖:Anthropic 黎曼猜想演示被指打乱数学家 GRH 证明发布
Marcus 转发的这篇长文把 Anthropic 的黎曼猜想演示和一位数学家 12 年的手工 GRH 证明放在一起对比,25 万页机器生成 Lean 与 940 页人工草稿的冲突写得很有细节。注意这是单方说法,两家都没有官方回应,适合当行业舆论观察来读,别当定论。
Gary Marcus 在 X 上转发 Alexey Fateev 的长文,声称 Anthropic 围绕 Claude 的黎曼猜想演示是一次"PR 表演",其后果是打乱了数学界一份人工证明的发布节奏。
帖中称,Levent Alpöge 的说明只有 4 页加 14 个机器生成的 Lean 包,转成散文超过 25 万页,他本人称其为"不可读的 slop";而 Alessandro Masullo 历时 12 年的 GRH 证明草稿被 AMS 主席 Ravi Vakil 仓促上线,共 940 页且零 AI 参与。
帖文描述 Brian Conrad 已对 Masullo 的证明核查数月,Vakil 评价"目前看没问题",两份证明均未通过同行评审。需要强调:以上均为社交媒体单方面叙述,Anthropic 与相关数学家的正式声明未在本帖中呈现,帖文本身也承认两份证明都可能在评审中被推翻。
must read about where we are now speaks deeply also to the fundamentally bad intellectual taste (if i can even call it that) of the tech bros who are cheering the wrong team here Alexey Fateev @superalesha Anthropic's PR circus just forced a real mathematician to dump 12 years of human work unfinished. Hours after their Claude Riemann Hypothesis stunt, AMS President Ravi Vakil hurriedly published a 940-page, ZERO AI proof of GRH by Alessandro Masullo. I opened both PDFs. The contrast is disgusting. Anthropic's Levent Alpöge gave the world a 4-page note and 14 tarballs of machine-generated Lean. In his own PDF he writes that turning it into prose hit 250,000+ pages, calling it "some massive unreadable travesty of 'slop'". He admits he hasn't mastered the math around it and is paraphrasing Claude's slop summaries that "might make zero sense". Sunday night he messaged Dario, and by Friday they blew up the internet with it. That same Sunday, Masullo and Stanford's Brian Conrad spent 4.5 hours at a blackboard at IAS walking Peter Sarnak through Masullo's proof. Conrad has been checking it closely for months, and Vakil wrote it's "so far looking good". They planned to bring Masullo back to Stanford for 1 year to finish polishing the writing. Instead, Vakil had to throw the raw draft online mid-meeting because Anthropic's fucking hype machine couldn't wait. Neither proof is verified yet, and either could still break under review. Even so, read Masullo's closing line on page 6 of his PDF: "If any message at all this work is meant to send to the mathematician who feels discouraged by the pace and tone of the current climate, it is this: we are still here. We are very much alive. We are not going anywhere." Anthropic dumped 250,000 pages of unreadable AI bullshit for attention. Masullo spent 12 years at a blackboard doing real math, and he didn't even get to finish the intro. 🔗 View Quoted Tweet📊 1 ⚡
本条情报归属 AITOP「行业」核心栏目,重点聚焦北美前沿实验室与硅谷科技巨头。在跨区域产业观察坐标中,该动态直接关联「中美大模型技术代差与商业化对照」研究主线,反映出当前技术演进与商业落地的最新风向。涉及核心实体与技术议题包括:Anthropic、Claude、Gary Marcus、GRH,读者可通过下方标签进入对应专题页查阅历史脉络与关联对比。
信源核验说明:本文原始线索采编自「Gary Marcus」(@GaryMarcus),经 AITOP 多维评分管线结构化提炼。截至目前,全网已有 11 家独立信源对该事件进行交叉印证与跟进报道(含 IT之家、kimmonismus、@koltregaskes 等),属于近期高关注度行业信号。